The 7 Retirement Questions That Matter More Than Your “Magic Number”
Stop chasing “enough.” Start engineering retirement resilience.
Charlie Munger said that “retirement isn’t a dream anymore. It’s a math problem that’s already been solved. Most people answer yes emotionally and no financially.”
If you’re within 7 years of retirement, the obsession with a single “Enough” number is understandable and dangerous.
The magic number seduces people because it’s simple. But the obsession can send you down a slippery slope.
That number moves with longevity, inflation, sequence of return risks, investment returns, spending rates, taxes and shocks.
Yet most people still go searching for the “Magical Number Button.”
Retirement readiness is not about optimism. It’s about building resilience and minimising every conceivable risk that might upend your retirement when you least expect it.
It’s the blind spots in retirement that will blow up your retirement plan.
The number one aim of your retirement plan is to ensure your retirement can withstand adverse markets and real-life surprises without forced decisions.
Your retirement can no longer absorb a big misstep like someone in their 20’s with decades to recover. Time is no longer on your side.
The Retire Once 7 Question Checklist
#1 Retirement Survival: Can you cover your core living expenses for multiple years (3-5) without selling your growth assets at the bottom of the market?
Why it matters: The years leading up to retirement and your first few years of retirement are where the sequence of return risk bites hard.
What to do: Aim to have access to 3-5 years of your core living expenses (put food on the table) in cash and low risk investments so you are not a price taker when markets fall.
Note: If you are in a single investment fund in your super and have been for many years, it’s time to review and prepare for your next phase.
#2 Separate Retirement Income Money from Growth Money: Do you have clearly labelled buckets within your super and investment accounts?
Why it matters: One blended bucket creates confusion and panic. Two or more bucket’s clarify purpose: pay for life vs grow life.
What to do: Pay your retirement income from cash and conservative investments. Invest the remainder for growth. Set rules to refill buckets in advance rather than on the fly…
Note: This is your oxygen when investment markets are suffocating you.
#3 Prioritise durable income over high yield: Which income sources will persist in hostile markets, and which are likely to wobble?
Why it matters: Reaching for high yield can increase the odds of cuts right when you can’t afford them.
What to do: Review all your income sources, income inside super, rental income, age pension and other pensions if applicable.
Note: High yields generally mean you are paying for risk, specifically, the risk that income won’t be there when markets turn nasty.
#4 Stress Test bad timing: If the first two years after you retire are down years, does your plan still work?
Why it Matters: Average returns can mislead. The order of returns is what retirees live through.
What to do: Model scenarios with early drawdowns. Test your ability to spend under those paths – not just rosy baselines.
Note: Our resolve is tested when panic sets in.
#5 Build flexibility into lifestyle: How much can you trim in a rough year without feeling deprived?
Why It Matters: A rigid lifestyle requires a perfect portfolio. A flexible lifestyle forgives imperfect markets.
What to do: Pre-define drawdowns (postpone travel, reduce gifts, skip car upgrade or retain amounts in buckets not exposed to markets) to keep decisions objective.
Note: A flexible plan builds retirement resilience which builds confidence.
#6 Ground your return expectations: Would 3-4% real returns for a decade still allow you to sleep at night?
Why it matters: Overly rosy assumptions push people into unnecessary risk and comparison-driven mistakes.
What to do: Test various return assumptions and see if the slow return plan breaks the plan. If so, review spending or work options. Don’t just “dial up” the portfolio risk or just take on debt.
Note: Many people take on unnecessary risk pre-retirement because they haven’t tested their numbers. They rely on a hope and prey approach – a slippery path that’s hard to recover from. Don’t confuse a bull market with brilliance. Markets don’t grade on a curve.
#7 Engineer behaviour: If markets fall 40% tomorrow, what would you actually do?
Why it matters: A plan must survive your reactions, not just the market.
What to do: Use rules. Set preset rebalancing bands, schedule income payments from the survival buckets and maybe a written “do-not-sell-in-panic” commitment.
Note: Independent research by Vanguard and Russell suggest the biggest value from working with a financial adviser is behaviour management. Often adding 1-2% pa over time by avoiding costly mistakes.
The fewer decisions you need to make in retirement, the safer you are. A retirement plan should be robust, not elegant.
Why this beats the “magic number?”
Numbers drift. Systems persist. You can’t control markets or headlines. You can control cash‑flow design, guardrails, and decision rules.
That control eases the emotional side. It’s jarring to watch your super balance fall once you stop contributing. Buckets, buffers, and rules reduce the urge to “fix” the portfolio at the worst time.
At 60, the accumulation game ends. A new game begins: preserve and protect what you’ve built and avoid risks you no longer have time to recover from.
Growth now means memories and experiences—not maximising returns.
This is the transition you must get right. You only get one shot.
Ready for clarity? If you plan to retire inside the next 7 years and you’re tired of wondering “Do we have enough?”, book a complimentary Retirement Clarity Call.
- No products. No pressure.
- A friendly chat about where you are, what’s challenging, and your best options.
- Leave with clear next steps and confidence about your retirement income
Glenn Doherty – CFP – Financial Planner | Retirement Planning Specialist |Retirement Planning Made Simple for over 55’s within 7 years of retirement.
We work with people in Adelaide and around Australia virtually via zoom!
Request a Retirement Clarity Call
An opportunity to talk through some of your challenges and questions you have around your retirement.
Achieve some clarity and maybe a roadmap on how you can achieve a comfortable retirement.
Schedule hereAdvice Disclaimer: Any reference in this publication to the provision of advice refers to advice of a generic nature, and should not be taken as product or investment recommendations. Before any action is taken based on the information provided, independent financial advice from a licensed financial adviser should be sought. Financial Freedom Project Pty Ltd ATF GA & DC Doherty Family Trust Trading as Jigsaw Private Wealth is a Corporate Authorised Representative of Spark Advisors Australia Pty Ltd. The information contained in this publication is of a factual nature only and is not intended to constitute financial product advice. Information is current as at date of publication. This is an online information blog. It does not imply an offering of securities.